|
|
Financial markets driven wild by hormones
THE behaviour of impetuous teenagers is often blamed on their hormones, but could these same chemicals drive the
economy? The suggestion is that the movement of money in the markets correlates with traders' levels of
testosterone, a hormone linked with aggression, and cortisol, the "stress hormone".
John Coates and Joe Herbert of the University of Cambridge monitored hormone swings in the saliva of 17 male
traders on a London trading floor over eight days. The swings were compared with the sums a trader made or lost,
and with market variations. When the traders made more money, their testosterone levels were higher, the
researchers report in Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences (DOI: 10.1073/pnas.0704025105). When markets
were volatile, they had elevated levels of cortisol.
But which is the cause and which the effect? Further analysis showed that traders who started their days with
extra testosterone made more money than those who didn't. One trader saw his testosterone levels soar by 74 per
cent during a six-day winning streak. From experiments in animals, we know that testosterone produces a "winner
effect", in which a victory raises levels of testosterone. This rise increases the chance of further victories.
Raised testosterone has also been shown to accelerate decision making - a critical skill in stock trading. "A lot
of trading is very short term," says Coates.
However, too much testosterone can lead to aggression and reckless decisions. And while elevated cortisol probably
contributes to better risk management in volatile situations, over the long term it can increase the risk of
cardiovascular disease and arthritis. "It also leads to shrinkage of brain regions associated with decision making
and factual memory," says Bruce McEwen of Rockefeller University, New York. It also enlarges regions associated
with anxiety.
That can trigger "learned helplessness", a sense of futility in risky situations. This could impede recovery from
the current slowdown. "What concerns me is not how far down the markets go, but for how long," says Coates, a
former trader. "These traders just slump down, and then don't respond to positive price indicators like interest
rate cuts, he says."
New Scientist From issue 2652, 19 April 2008, page 12
|
|